We recently received this movie in the mail via BlockBuster.com. I actually was really excited to this. I was expecting something a long the lines of the Tudors and I enjoy “period” movies, especially if they are based on “true events.”
Kiera Knightley stars as Her Grace, Georgiana Cavendish, Duchess of Devonshire or G, as she was called for short. I’m not the biggest Kiera Knightley fan. I enjoy her movies, but she tends to be overshadowed by excellent actors such as Johnny Depp and Stellan Skarsgard. And the biggest compliment to her is that she looks so much like Natalie Portman (whom I find to be an excellent actress). Knightley is not a terrible actress, quite the opposite, she’s rather good, but in the movies I’ve seen she allows herself to become washed out by other actors and leaves her character in the cold. I honestly think Elizabeth Swann was just a pretty face to stir up romantic interests. She was not needed for the story to progress.
This movie is no different, except what washes her out isn’t other actors. The story itself is simply dull. I’ll come back to that. Knightley is our main character, so she cannot be washed out by the other actors because they support her. She also wears an elaborate wardrobe and speaks quite sophisticatedly to her male counterparts in politics and delightful conversation. I didn’t know anything about the Duchess of Devonshire’s history, but this movie indicates that she was the English Marie Antoinette. Instead of shoes, Her Grace was known for delightful conversation and her self designed wardrobe.
The movie begins interesting enough. Georgiana (pronounced George + Jane + uh) is not yet 18 and is married off to the Duke of Devonshire (a much older man, of course). She is told that her duties as wife is to be loving, kind, and to produce a male heir. Upon giving birth to a boy, she will then be compensated. Yes, ladies and gentleman, she will be paid to have a baby.
Well, there are little ripples and then huge tidal waves in her and the Duke’s marriage. A little girl named Charlotte comes to live with them a few months after their marriage and we are led to believe that this little girl was fathered by the Duke. Not only that, but the Duke’s extra curricular marital affairs are made quite clear when a shot of a maid’s naked behind is seen running down the hall from the Duke’s bed chamber.
The story is basically how Georgiana deals with such obscenities. Do not forget that during this time, affairs were still scandalous, though the men ran around often. In trying to deal with his extra marital affairs, G finds comfort in her friend Elizabeth Foster, known as Bess for the rest of the movie. Bess comes to live with the Duke and Duchess because she was divorcing her first husband.
Long story short, the Duke ends up having an affair with Bess, which causes a huge rift in G’s marriage and her friendship with Bess. I saw this coming from a mile away. The worst part was that G could send her away from her own home. The Duke would not allow it. It seems that G had the first publicized plural marriage, so to speak. Bess lived with them until Georgiana’s death and married the Duke after it.
It is during this time that G has an affair with a local politician, Mr. Grey. Up to this point G has had 3 children (2 girls: Harryo and Little G) and 1 son (Hart) with the Duke. She also gives birth to another daughter named Eliza fathered by Mr. Grey and ended up giving her away to Grey’s family.
There really is no climax. The emotion in this movie is not only over the top, but overwhelming, and not even close to making me feel upset. I understood that G was angry that her husband’s mistress decided to live with her and also move her own sons in as well. I was also upset that she had to stop her affair with Mr. Grey due to impropriety and scandals in the papers about it.
There really is not much more to make of this movie. If there was a climax, I missed it, and if there was a plot, well I missed that too. I really felt like I was watching a documentary about their marriage than a movie. The worst part about that would be the documentary might actually be more enjoyable. Her Grace sounds like a fascinating history lesson, but she does not do well on the silver screen.
The movie was approximately 2 hours long, short compaired to most and by 50 minutes I was checking the timer to see how much longer I had to sit through. I was interesting to find out what happened, but since she became friends with Bess again and decided to accept all that was happening to her, I was disappointed with the ending of the movie. I was, however, relieved for it to be over.
Knightley delivers a so, so performance at best. She did well capturing the essence of Her Grace as a witty and charming socialite, but added no more interest to the story than that. It was difficult to connect the actors to the time period because, as my boyfriend said, Knightley looks too modern for the role. It was also hard to connect with the character on any type of level, emotional or otherwise. I was just waiting for the movie to be over, missing plot and climax all in the process.
I wouldn’t really recommend this movie. You’re probably better off reading about Her Grace, the Duchess of Devonshire or finding a documentary on her. At least then you will have true facts to work with and not just a soddy Hollywood money maker.
P.S. An interesting tidbit is revealed at the beginning of this movie. Georgiana is born of the House of Spencer. She is a direct relative to the late Princess Diana (also born of the House of Spencer).